Shiur Hashkafa, 5784

These shiurim were given on Thursdays in Y.U., to Rav Twersky’s shiur.

  • Listen using the player below
  • Click the “track lyrics” button  or see the table below the audio player to read a detailed description of a shiur
  • Click the download button  next to a shiur to download that shiur

See the table below the player for details about the shiurim in this series.

TrackTitleLengthDescription
1Nach-pe-sa…v’nachkora33:333 explanations of “Nach-pe-sa…v’nachkora…v’nashuva”
1) Shaarei Teshuva, Shaar 3: have to take inventory of what sins I have, then look at the magnitude of each sin. The magnitude of the sin has to be reflected in the teshuva and in the magnitude of busha one feels.
2) Zohar: nachkora == figuring out how to correct the cheit and how do make sure not to do it anymore.
3) Cheit has a context & root. Nachkora == figuring out how this cheit happened. This and Zohar are 2 sides of the same coin.
2Busha. Relative Severity of Different Types of Aveiros.41:07– The degree of busha in teshuva, and in both asking and receiving mechila, should be proportionate to the magnitude of the aveira.

– D’oraysa more chamur than d’rabbanan because d’oraysa HKB”H communicated directly to us, more of a chutzpa to ignore. Same type of difference between mefurash b’kra and understood via a drasha.

– One often goes against a d’rabbanan due to taking it lightly, and that attitude is rebellious (like zakein mamreh) and very chamur.
3Divrei Chachomim. Schar for Mitzvas Aseh.38:08Shaarei Teshuva, Shaar 3:6.
– Severity of transgressing divrei chachomim.

– Observing dinei d’rabanan a fuller expression of yiras Shomayim

– Reward only for mitzvos aseh or lo sa’aseh as well. Machlokes, explanation.
4Approach to Miztzvos Aseh, Lo Sa’aseh. Lifnim Mishuras Hadin.42:42Shaarei Teshuva, starting from 3:9
– Why reward for miztvos aseh isn’t specified.
– Severity of being dismissive of mitzvos.
– Nature of the obligation to go lifnim mishuras hadin.
5Yiras ha’Onesh, Yiras ha’Romemus37:00Sha’arei Ohr, Rab Itzele Blazer
– yiras ha’onesh, yiras ha’romemus. Can’t skip yiras ha’onesh.

– a knowledge-based sustained awareness of yiras Hashem

– why yiras ha’onesh is not mentioned in Mishna Torah, and yiras ha’romemus is not mentioned in Sefer Hamitzvos
Related to track #10 here.
6Daily Teshuva & Living Reflectively39:37– Two different reasons to always do teshuva: 1) should die b’kedusha v’tahara and 2) to LIVE that way

– Yetzer Hara works naturally without premeditation. Yetzer hatov comes from reflection. If one coasts through life, Yetzer hara will be dominant. Daily teshuva defined as not drifting away from HKBH, each day and instead coming closer each day
7Introduction. Ikar #1.37:14– What’s the difference between one not knowing the 13 ikarim vs. any other part of Torah?

– Why aren’t they presented as a list by Chazal?

– First ikar: no existence independent of HKB”H.
8Yichud Hashem. Incorporeality.32:31– ikar #2: yichud Hashem, unique and singular.

– ikar #3: HKB”H isn’t physical. Torah uses anthropomorphisms to describe Him to make it easier for us to grasp various points better.
9Ikar #3 (Incorporeality of HKB”H) and #4 (HKB”H Coming Before All Else)35:44See Hilchos Teshuva 3:7, Hilchos Shechita 4:14, Hilchos Mamrim 3:1,3.
Machlokes Rambam & Ra’avad in Teshuva 3:7 if someone can believe in minus without having a din of a min.
Rambam: Torah doesn’t expect everyone to figure out Elokus on his on, but does expect us to defer to those who are greater than us, hence one is a min for believing that HKB”H is corporeal.
10Ikar 5, 633:35– Ikar 5: serve only Hashem. No intermediaries. Davening for others.
– Ikar 6: nevuah. Definition of nevuah is that it’s experienced by an adam hashalem.
11Ikar 748:17Ikar 7: nevuah of Moshe is different in kind, not just degree. Details of the differences.
12Ikar #8 – Torah Min haShomayim39:15– Torah today is that same Torah.
– Torah she’bal peh & b’ksav.
– Difference between peirushim ha’mekubalim and halacha l’Moshe misinai? Why the later not mentioned in ikar 8?
– How does navi fits in?
– the immutability of Torah.
13Ikarim 9 – 1237:359 – Torah doesn’t change
10 – HKB”H knows ma’asei bnei Adam and exercises hashgacha (both included on yediah)
11 – sechar v’onesh, the former really being in olam haba. Why not listed on perek 3 of teshuva? Included in yediah.
12 – yemos hamoshiach (not only melech hamoshiach).
14Beginning of Hakdama to Perek Chelek58:08Sechar v’onesh is widely misunderstood in terms of what olam haba is, what mashiach brings, etc. Rambam discusses the correct understanding, as well as the definition of ahavas Hashem and lishma.
15The Eternal vs. the Finite35:14– The nature of something eternal is completely different than the finite.
– People are willing to endure amal and yegiah for kavod, for revenge, etc. That’s prioritizingg non-physical ta’anug.
– “Rewards” in olam hazeh are just to enable our avoda.
16Attitude Towards Mitzvos43:20Our attitude towards mitzvos is an essential part of our fulfilling them. Kiyum haMitzvos == to do it lishma, mei’ahava.
17Techiyas Hameisim, Moshiach37:33– after techiyas hameisim, people will die again
– how the world will function during yemos hamoshiach
– the melech hamoshiach
– the process leading up to moshiach
18Being Human, Reaching Olam Habba36:12– the ultimate goal is olam habba. How does one get there? Serve HKB”H out of love.
– to be truly human is to serve HKB”H, which is what differentiates us from animals, and leads us to olam habba.
– have to teach the klalim before can get into the subtleties and nuances, so don’t complain about the Rambam not filling out every last detail.
19Definition of Apikores, Other Causes for Losing Olam Habba38:39– apikores = zilzul towards yesodos haTorah or talmidei chachomim. There is no greater zilzul than not believing in ikraim.
– Why does the mishna mention spcifically teschiyas hameisim and Torah min haShomyaim?
– What is uniquely bad about wasting time by reading koreh b’seforim chitzonim?
– locheish el makkos, writing names of melachim in mezuzos, etc. – reducing Torah to some kind of first aid kit, etc.
20The Status “Yisroel”37:37– The status “Yisroel” depends on being a ma’amin, and the chiyuvim bein adam lachaveiro applying depend on the recipient being a Yisroel. Only b’Toras Yisroel does one have a chelek in olam habba.
– Hilchos De’os – ahavas Yisroel more limited, while in Hilchos Aveilus more expansive because dealing with achicha b’mitzvos. Mechayev in De’os is keeping one’s own middos good, in aveil it’s v’ahavata l’rei’a’cha kamocha.
21Hakdama to Mishna Torah: Torah vs. Mitzvah42:23– What’s Torah vs. mitzvah? Torah is b’ksav, mitzvah is b’al peh.
– “Torah b’ksav” describes both the cheftza and how it is passed on. “Torah she’B’al peh” only describes how it is passed on, but the cheftza is “peirush”.
– there are many pesukim in which Rambam gives multiple different peshatim in Mishna Torah; pesukim are intended to mean multiple things.
22Hakdama to Mishna Torah, 2: Why Torah She’b’al Peh is Referred to as “Mitzvah”39:24Mitzvah – command, interpretation, legacy from generation to generation. Rambam using all these meanings, and this answers many questions.