Ramban Al haTorah, 5783-5784

These shiurim were given at 12pm on Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday in Y.U., to Rav Twersky’s shiur.

  • Listen using the player below
  • Click the “track lyrics” button  or see the table below the audio player to read a detailed description of a shiur
  • Click the download button  next to a shiur to download that shiur

See the table below the player for details about the shiurim in this series.

TrackTitleLengthDescription
1Devarim 30:11 – “ki haMitzvah hazos”20:39Devarim 30:11 – “ki haMitzvah hazos” – refers to teshuva. “v’shavta” means both chiyuv & havtacha. “V’hasheivosa el levavecha” also refers to teshuva. V’hasheivosa means to be misbonein on the trouble we experienced, which will then awaken us to “v’shavta”. Tzara is mechayeiv in cheshbon haNefeshm, which in turn leads to teshuva.
2Types of Teshuva31:28Tzara is mechayeiv in cheshbon hanefesh. Kol Dodi Dofeik, f.n. #3: difference between general mitzvas teshuva & eis tzara – chiyuv to do teshuva in general comes from already having awareness of cheit, while an eis tzara requires us to proactively look for cheit.

Ramban says our parsha is a havtacha that Bnai Yisroel will do teshuva. on the end of the shira in Ha’azinu he says: the geula will come even without teshuva. Which is it? If the geula comes without our doing teshuva, then we will subsequently do teshuva as a response to the geula.

Ramban: teshuva is ledoros, “ah’ta u’banecha”. This refers to a higher level of teshuva, which is associated with geula and brings us to acharis haYomim, is final.
3u’mal Hashem Elokecha es levavcha24:30Devarim 30:6 – “u’mal Hashem Elokecha es levavcha…l’ma’an chayecha”
Ramban: What’s milas halev? Pshat 1) “Habo litaheir, mesayin oso.” Pshat 2) in days of Moshiach, human nature will be different – people will be “sichli”, i.e. we will not be conflicted between good and bad.
Rambam 9:2 – “ein bein…” – no change in human nature. How did Rambam learn pshat in the pesukim the Ramban quotes? Radak: “Eini kol elecha yisabeiru…” means HKB”H set up teva that everything finds its food b’ito. Rambam would say that in the days of Moshiach, HKB”H will set up a spiritual climate in the world where all those pesukim will play out naturally.
4Hashem’s Help with Teshuva15:31Rambam (Hilchos Teshuva 6:5): a person on the right path wants to continue on it, and that’s “habo litaheir mesayin oso” – not that Hashem intervenes, but that there’s positive momentum felt by the person and he wants to continue.

R’ Yona: beginning of Sha’arei Teshuva – as long as a person does as much as he can do to do teshuva, HKB”H finishes the job and takes him the rest of the way. (Chovos Halevavos says same point about ahavas Hashem, Ramchal says it about kedusha.)

We shouldn’t give up because we can’t make it all the way – if we go as far as we can, HKB”H takes us the rest of the way.
5Zichron Teruah27:36– explanation of “zichron Teruah” according to Ramban and Rashi

– shofar as the vehicle causing our zicharon to come before Hashem and trigger His mercy

– Explanation of how we know the yom Teruah that comes before Yom Kippur must be a yom hadin. Obligation to try to hold ourselves to ideal standards, not default immediately to relying on rachamim.
6Din, Zichron Teruah, and Simcha18:03Rav Hutner (Y”K, 29:1-5)” R”H is elevated from being a yom hadin to being a yom tov via zichron teruah.
Explanation as to why every day of simcha / yom tov is also a day of din (as listed in mishna R”H 16a).
7Degrees of Teshuva21:52– “Ach be’asor lachodesh” – according to the chachomim, the mi’ut indicates that it is not Y”K for the person who doesn’t do teshuva; tehuva is mechaper on Y”K, Y”K is not an independent mechaper for which teshuva is a prerequisite.

– There are degrees of hakoras hacheit –> degrees of teshuva –> degrees of kapara.
8Issur Melacha & Teshuva. Sukkos Mamash.28:55– “Ach be’asor”: how fasting and issue melacha each contribute to teshuva

– “ki baSukkos Hoshavti es Bnei Yisroel”: the message if one assumes it means physical sukkos (two opinions – Ramban and Rambam.)
9Accountability30:26– First Ramban on Chumash: starting from Breishis teaches us how HKB”H’s hashgacha works, i.e. there are consequences to our actions.

– The notion of accountability, yiras ha’onesh, is not something that is spoken about in this generation, and the omission is wrong. What’s happening in Eretz Yisroel is a middas hadin. Airbrushing out yiras ha’onesh is a distortion of Yahadus.

– Describing Yahadus in exclusively warm & fuzzy terms and our not taking firm stands are parallel.
10Rambam, Hilchos Teshuva, Yiras ha’Onesh16:25Yiras ha’onesh is not something we are supposed to ever outgrow. Yahadus is not a religion OF fear, but is one WITH fear.
also see track #5 here
11Intuitive Natural Morality, the Hypocrisy and Evil of Some Reactions to the Massacre in Israel20:35– Ramban, Breishis, 6:13: chomos-theft is more egregious because it’s intuitive that it’s wrong, and one can’t plead ignorance or blame its prevalence in society. Hakdama of R’ Nissim Gaon to Shas: all humans are obligated in that which is intuitive.
– Rambam, Hilchos Teshuva 5:1: people have free choice and the innate ability to recognize natural good from natural bad.
– There is zero excuse for the hypocrisy and evil in the world in the reactions to what happened in Israel. It is nothing less than pure evil. Those who provide verbal cover for Hamas have blood on their hands.
– Rav zt”l: when society defies natural morality, the world can’t function. We see empirical evidence of this in today’s world.
– Our efforts have to be as sustained as those of the Chayalim etc.
12Noach’s Children. Noach vs. Moshe.21:57– Shem, Chom, Yafes saved as Noach’s children. Two possibilities why.

– Why Noach was spared from the judgement against the entire world (Hilchos Teshuva 3:2), while Moshe was included in the gzeira on his generation to not go into Israel.
13Tzedek, Tzedaka, Tamim.17:17– tzedek == din/innocence, tzedakka == rachamim.

– “Tamim” – wholly innocent
14Which of the 7 Miztvos Benei Noach Are Intuitive?17:59Resolution to seeming contradictions in both the Ramban and Rambam regarding whether the 7 mitzvos are intuitive or not.
15Mitzvos Sichliyos Being Obligatory21:45– sources that they’re obligatory
– multiple halachic implications of their being obligatory
16Natural and Commanded Ahavas Hashem16:45Rambam Hilchos Yesodei haTorah 2:2 and Hilchos Teshuva 10:2 state one definition/part of ahavas Hashem, Sefer Hamitzvos, Mitzvas Aseh 3 and Hilchos Teshuva 10:5 add another.
17An Eved Hashem Lives, and Merits Hashgacha, as an Individual16:27Ramban 18:19, ki yeda’ativ. Hashem knows the chassid as an individual. Explanation from Ish Halacha.
18Ye’di’ah and Hashgacha16:03Ramban, on ki yeda’ativ: being known by HKB”H is, itself, to have hashgacha.
19Avraham’s Uniqueness, Justice Divinely Defined23:4218:18 according to Rashi, Ramban, and Rambam – highlighting what is special about Avraham and understanding darkei Hashem.
20The Point of Challenges. The Impact of Intentions.18:01– the point of challenges is l’hotzi min ha’koach el ha’poal, in order to increase his reward.
– reward and punishment for attitude & intention, independent of outcome
21The More One Wants, the More One is Missing18:38We have a quality of being insatiable, there’s always more to do, the question is where we channel it – money or mitzvos.
22Mesora. Eretz Yisroel.23:55– the slander of leitzonei hador about Yitzchok’s paternity.
– biological vs. spiritual descendants.
– Avos only kept kol haTorah kula in Eretz Yisroel
23Ma’aseh Avos Siman Labanim24:5112:6 – ma’aseh avos siman labanim; experience of avos as a po’el dimyon which makes a gezeira enter this world. Rav zt”l’s explanation of how this works with bechira chofshis.
24Ma’aseh Avos Siman Labanim, part 226:1412:10 – ma’aseh avos siman labanim – role of cheit in Avraham going to Mitzrayim and in galus Mitzrayim.
25Hishtadlus & Bitachon22:4032:4 – HKB”H saves his servants, but must do our best hishtadlus. Halacha functions on a natural plane (see, e.g., choleh on Shabbos.)
26War & Emunah15:30Devarim 20:1 – kohein frames things supernaturally, shotrim frame them naturally.
Ibid 9 – Torah commands us to act on a natural level, with emunah that HKB”H is poised to perform miracles.
27Bitachon and Hishtadlus12:16Bitachon and hishtadlus are both supposed to be present, and one should not be incorrectly reduced because of the other.
28Ramban on Doctors30:12Ramban on Doctors in Different Eras
29Jewish Monarchy44:43Permissibility, and status, of kings not from Beis Dovid. Status of malchus Beis Chashmonai.
30Chanukah Extending the Beis Hamikdash16:02HKB”H’s consolation to Aharon in Beha’aloscha via his involvement in neiros Chanukah which last even after churban bayis.
31Status of Mitzvos D’rabbanan.15:52Why are mitzvos derabanan not bal tosif? Shitos of Rambam and Ramban, connection to previous shiur.
32Ramban Hakdama to Shemos23:05⁃ Galus and geulas mitzray not defined in terms of E”Y
⁃ Hakdama to vayikra – vayikra all about kohanim and leviim, ie Mitzvos which help avoid siluk ha shechina.
33Ramban Hakdama to Vayikra21:39⁃ Galus and geulas mitzray not defined in terms of E”Y
⁃ Hakdama to vayikra – vayikra all about kohanim and leviim, ie Mitzvos which help avoid siluk ha shechina.
34Anochi Hashem22:00– Anochi, Havaya: He is existence and all existence exists through Him. Elokim: kol yachol. Yetzias Mitzrayim provides proof for anochi – supernatural nissim show that the world is His creation, under His exclusive control, etc.
– Ramban & Rambam count anochi as a mitzva, Bahag doesn’t because a mitzvah presupposes a Metzaveh, so it’s a prerequisite/axiom for mitzvos. Ramban & Rambam say it includes more than there being a metzaveh and hence can be counted.
35Anochi Hashem, Part 222:54– “Mibeis avodim”: why we have more of an obligation to serve Him. Lashon yachid to tell us that we’re each individually obligated even though Torah was given to the Klal as a whole.
– “Lo yihiye lecha”: Rashi quotes not to own avodah zara. Ramban – we don’t pasken like that opinion as pshat here, rather this is to not believe and elevate avodah zara to be a deity.
36Goy Kadosh46:21What is means to be a goy kadosh, and the role the mishkan played in fulfilling that mission.
3721:29
3820:39
3942:46
4024:32
4135:48
4220:11
4321:07
4415:50
4525:21
4622:04
4729:29
4816:23
4923:08